It's the Tuesday before Week 1. You've got last season's CBS pool link, a group text with 23 people in it and a note on your phone that says who has paid. Eleven names have a check mark.

CBS will run the picks for free. The money is still your problem.

That's the real story of this comparison. Below, Splash Sports and the CBS Sports survivor pool go setting by setting, from mulligans to payouts, seen through the eyes of the person who has to run the thing.

Quick verdict on Splash vs CBS Sports

Splash for cash pools, CBS for free ones

Our pick: SPLASH SPORTS

Splash Sports is the pick for commissioners who handle real money

CBS wins on cost: its pool tools are free and its mulligan setting goes deep. Splash wins on the parts that eat a commissioner's week: collecting entries, paying winners, flexible rules and reports that run themselves.

Scored 0 to 10 on each criterion, by the Splash editorial team

CriterionSplash SportsOur pickCBS Sports
Real-money payouts10/10 ✓3/10
Collecting entry fees9/10 ✓4/10
Rule settings9/10 ✓6/10
Second chances9/10 ✓7/10
Reports & pick data9/10 ✓6/10
Cost to start6/1010/10 ✓
Total52/6036/60

The CBS survivor pool lives inside CBS Football Pick'em, which sits in the same family as CBS Sports Fantasy football and the CBS bracket games. You can see the whole lineup on the CBS Sports fantasy games hub.

It's a capable free tool. One NFL pick a week, no repeats, plus mulligans, a restart button and a setting that keeps the pool alive if everyone loses.

But CBS never moves the money. Its Finances page is a ledger: CBS can do the payout math, but you mark who paid and who got paid out.

Splash Sports is built for the pool where the money matters. Entry fees go into a prize pool, Splash collects them, and winners get paid automatically when the contest ends.

If you're the one holding the envelope, Splash is the pick.

How Splash survivor works

One team a week, no take-backs

An NFL survivor pool is the simplest game in football and the cruelest. Pick one team to win each week. Right pick, you advance. Wrong pick, you spend a life. Out of lives, you're out.

By default, a team you use is gone for the rest of the contest. Picks lock automatically at kickoff and stay hidden until then, so nobody gets to copy the sharpest player in the group.

Splash runs it as a peer-to-peer contest. You're playing your friends and other fans, not the house. Join a Guaranteed Contest or create a private one, then let the scoring run itself. Wins, losses and eliminations tally in real time, and the leaderboard updates the moment games end.

The Splash NFL survivor pool app runs on iOS and Android, with a web app at app.splashsports.com for the friend who refuses to download anything. Members get nudged before the pick deadline, and you can track live scores and rankings while chatting with your group.

Tip

Someone always forgets. On Splash, the commissioner can drop in a pick for a member who missed the deadline, even after lock.

NFL survivor pool app features compared

Where the two pools split apart

Both products cover the basics. The gap opens at the edges, and the edges are where commissioners get yelled at. Here's the side by side, built from CBS's own help center and the Splash game page.

Splash Survivor vs the CBS Sports survivor pool, checked October 2026

Splash SportsOur pickCBS Sports
Real-money prizesYes, peer-to-peer prize poolsNo, the Finances page tracks fees only
Entry fee collectionSplash collects entries and pays winnersCommissioner collects, CBS keeps the ledger
Second chances1 to 5 lives, raise the cap to revive, buybacksMulligans, up to 18 per player
Team reuseOnce by default, up to five times or unlimitedOnce per season
Pick typeWinners or losers, straight up or ATSWinners, straight up or ATS
Everyone loses in one weekAuto-revival gives the field a life backOptional setting plays on until one winner
LeaguesNFL, college football or bothNFL

Splash survivor settings & revivals

Every rule your group argues about, settled

The Splash Survivor game lets you set the contest up preseason and adjust it all year.

Lives come first. Give each entry 1 to 5, and raise the cap mid-season if you want to bring back anyone knocked out under the smaller one. If the whole field busts in the same week, auto-revival hands everyone a life and the contest keeps going.

Then the format. Pick winners, or flip the contest so everyone picks losers. Score it straight up or against the spread, with spreads from Splash or entered by you. Team-use limits run from once to five times to unlimited, with a separate cap on picking against a team.

Then the chaos controls. Multi-pick weeks on the dates you choose, or automatically once the field thins. A bye pick for the member who forgets one Sunday. Auto-picks that fill a missed pick with the home or away favorite, or at random. Late entry, with a lives penalty for anyone who joins after Week 1.

And the ending. Ties can split, or a single-winner tiebreaker decides it by weeks survived, championship total or net margin. For how those choices change your picks, read our breakdown of revivals & tiebreakers.

CBS Sports survivor pool features

A free tool with a few smart toggles

The CBS Sports survivor pool follows the classic format. Each week you pick one NFL team to win, you can use a team only once all season, and a wrong pick eliminates you unless the manager has turned on mulligans.

Mulligans are the standout. A pool manager can allow up to 18 per participant, and a mulligan covers a wrong pick or a missed one. The count can go up after Week 1 but never below what someone has already used, and a team that cost you a mulligan stays off limits.

Two more toggles handle the endgame. Continue pool if everyone loses keeps the pool going until a single winner is left. Ties count as wins advances everyone on a team that ties. Both can be changed only through Week 1. Once a winner is crowned, Start New Round reboots the pool for another run, as long as Week 18 hasn't ended.

Around that, a CBS football pool gets four deadline choices, from game by game to Sunday at 1pm ET, optional pick percentages, an optional message board and offline players whose picks the manager enters. CBS says there's no limit on how many players can join.

Entry fees & payouts

A ledger is not a payout

Here's where the two products stop looking alike.

CBS gives commissioners a Finances page. You enter an entry fee, one-time or weekly, and choose how winnings get tracked. Pick Track Winnings for me and CBS calculates weekly and season payouts by dollar amount or percentage. Pick the manual option and you type in each member's winnings yourself.

Either way, the Paid and Paid Out columns are yours to fill in. CBS keeps score of the money. It doesn't move it. Collecting is still your job, whether that means Venmo requests or an envelope in the break room.

Splash is a survivor pool app that handles the money end to end. Splash securely collects entries and pays out winners. When the contest ends, winnings are paid automatically and funds are immediately available for withdrawal. Payments are processed through Paysafe.

Would you rather hold the pot yourself? Contest Vault, built through a direct integration with LeagueSafe, lets commissioners collect, hold and pay out entry fees in one place.

Current offers and contest details show in the app.

Where Splash wins

Your pool, minus the accounting

  • Real-money prize pools, with entries collected and winners paid automatically.
  • More rules to set: pick-the-loser, team-use limits, multi-pick weeks, auto-picks and a single-winner tiebreaker.
  • NFL, college football or a combined contest, with college narrowed to specific conferences if you like.
  • Reports that update as games end, from the survival grid to availability charts.

Where CBS Sports wins

Free & deep on mulligans

  • Free to use with a CBS Sports account.
  • Up to 18 mulligans per player, against 1 to 5 lives per entry on Splash.
  • No cap on pool size, plus offline players the manager can pick for.
  • Start New Round lets a finished pool run again before Week 18 ends.

Legality & states

Check your state before you collect a dime

CBS's pool manager is open to registered users who are 18 or the age of majority in their state, whichever is older. Its terms call the service void where prohibited and add a line every commissioner should read twice: "It is incumbent upon you to know the laws that pertain to you in your jurisdiction."

Translation: if your CBS pool has money attached, the legal homework is yours.

Splash's own FAQ makes a related point about knockout pools in general. Whether they're allowed depends on whether a state treats them as games of skill or chance, and entry fees and prizes can bring extra rules.

Splash publishes the answer state by state. It offers legal play for real money in most of the US and Canada, including all of Canada except Quebec. Location verification is required by law before you deposit or join a contest, and the minimum age is 18+, 19+ or 21+ depending on the state. Format availability varies too, and some states are available with no NCAA contests.

Check where you can play before you send the invite.

Promos & boosts

CBS prizes live in a separate challenge

Your private CBS pool has no deposit offers, because nothing gets deposited. CBS puts its prize play in a different game: the free 2026 CBSSports.com Pro Football Pick'em Contest.

That's a national against-the-spread challenge, not your survivor pool. The official rules list $1,000 to each week's top scorer across 18 weeks, $5,000 for the best season and a $100,000 prize for a perfect week that also nails both tiebreaker scores, split if more than one player hits it. Entry is free for registered users of legal age who live in a US state, as of October 2026.

Splash keeps its offers in the app, where they stay current. Promotions change, so you won't find a promo code printed here. The Splash Discord also posts special promos alongside product news.

An offer lasts a week. Your rules last all season.

Head to head for pool commissioners

Who does the work on Sunday

Most survivor pool sites get judged on the pick screen. Commissioners should judge them on everything around it: the chores, the arguments and the money.

Start with the chores. On CBS, the manager sets the deadline, toggles mulligans and enters picks for anyone playing as an offline player. On Splash, picks lock at the deadline you select, used teams are blocked on the picksheet, eliminations tally themselves and you can enter a pick for a member even after lock.

Then the arguments. CBS locks its tie and everyone-loses settings after Week 1, which keeps things fair but leaves little room to fix a rule nobody saw coming. Splash lets you adjust all year, including raising the lives cap to revive the field.

Then the money, which is where the best survivor pool website for a cash pool gets decided. CBS tracks it. Splash collects it and pays it out.

Tip

Running a weekly pool too? Put both on the same platform so your group has one login, one leaderboard habit and one place to pay.

Plenty of groups run a weekly pool alongside survivor. The CBS Pick em lobby covers NFL and college, with straight-up, against-the-spread and weighted options, and CBS Sports Pick em pools cost nothing to create, same as the survivor game.

Splash Pick'em adds custom scoring, drop weeks, a Monday-night tiebreaker, auto-picks and late entry. If that's next on your list, here's how to host a pick'em pool without the spreadsheet.

Pick the format. Set the lives. Let Splash handle the payout.

Frequently asked questions

Quick answers for the commish

Yes, as of October 2026. CBS's terms say there's no charge to become a registered user, and its create-a-pool flow lists no price. The catch is the money. The CBS Finances page tracks entry fees and payouts, but the commissioner still collects and pays them, and CBS describes the service as entertainment only.

Yes. Splash securely collects entries and pays out winners automatically when the contest ends, with funds immediately available for withdrawal. Commissioners who want to hold the money can turn on Contest Vault, built through an integration with LeagueSafe, to collect, hold and pay out entry fees in one place. Availability varies by state, so check before you invite.

Yes, by rebuilding it rather than importing it. Create a Survivor contest, match your CBS rules (lives in place of mulligans, straight up or against the spread), then invite your group and manage it from the Commissioner Hub. Splash's Commissioner Training Camp series includes an article on importing your list. Late entry with a lives penalty helps if you switch mid-season.

Up to 18 per participant, set by the pool manager. A mulligan covers a wrong or missed pick. The number can rise after Week 1 but never drop below what any member has used, and the team that cost you a mulligan can't be picked again. Splash uses lives instead, 1 to 5 per entry, with revivals and buybacks.

CBS says there's no limit. Each CBS account gets one entry in a football pick'em pool, so a second entry means a second account. Managers can also add offline players on the web and enter their picks for them. On Splash, you can run a private contest for your own group or join a public one.

Play on the go

Take Splash Sports with you

Make your picks, track live scoring, and cash out instantly from anywhere. The Splash app puts every contest (Survivor, QuickPicks, Pick'Em and brackets) in your pocket, free on iOS and Android.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

More from the Splash blog